Hatred: Theirs or Yours

Let it come

like wildflowers, suddenly, because

the field must have it: wildpeace.

- Yahuda Amichai

Unless we are without much contact across the planet, we live in a time of serious anxiety and stress. All over the world, across our communities and perhaps within our own families, we are witnessing or directly experiencing an unleashing of frayed and violent regression to hatred.

Almost every survivor has experienced hatred in some form. Perhaps you have known the blanket of fear, powerlessness and rage if you are the one where it is directed. Or perhaps, if you are honest, you have felt an almost aphrodisiac giddiness if you are the one directing it to an other, especially if you act on it with violence or active vitriol.

Hatred is a fever. You may be a product of trauma of racial and religious oppression, or your own upbringing and personal history of abuse. You may understand hatred toward those who are other, whether you know them or not. Or more personally, you may harbor visceral contempt toward those who have abused you or your communities. Whatever harm has been done, there is a history of bigotry or violence either as a target or as a perpetrator of the hatred. You witness this in a world of severe political and civic unrest, with raw generalities of hatred and violence toward whole groups of people. You yourself may be a casualty of racial or religious aggression and violence, or the personal experience of demoralizing abuse and defilement and denial within your own family.

The inevitable consequences. Hatred can overtake your mind and especially your heart. This poison can create a sense or fantasy of entitlement to retribution. It is not necessarily justice.

It is almost impossible to be unaffected by hatred in all its forms. It can weaken the immune system, raise blood pressure and affect the ability to rest. It can create disease, depression, addiction or a learned reenactment of internalized self loathing. It can destroy a sense of one's own humanity as it reverberates back on us. This is not only a remnant of hatred, but an inevitable result of living inside its toxicity.

It is not an easy thing to release yourself from this. To say to a survivor, "You can choose to let it go," is easier said than done. But you may already know that if you choose to hold onto the armor of hatred, there can be profound consequences that will not serve you breaking free.

The journey of healing. It can take a lot of time to heal from the direct experience of hatred or the memories that still live in your body. It is not enough to simply remove yourself, although it may be crucial to keep a distance. Space is both a physical and a cognitive reality. You may not be able to relocate geographically, or easily reconfigure your neighborhood or family, unless the situation is so intolerable it warrants a move.

There needs to be a place to be free enough not only to rant and rave, but to be still and quiet. It is important to find a community that is safe enough to do both, where you can think things through, and get or give understanding, and to release some of the anger, the deep fear or hurt you carry.

Letting it go. It is essential to consider what it means to let go of hatred. Often you are asked to forgive. But forgiveness is often misconstrued in response to those who have harmed you. It is often far more complicated and nuanced to cover with platitudes, and too easily glossed over even in therapy or in pastoral care.

Recovery from hatred is a journey of grief. It takes time and respect for all the rage and loss, pain and betrayal that has transpired in your life. But what is possible, albeit some work--is to find a way to let go and release yourself from the aggression you have suffered and embodied.

Building compassion. One way that I have found helpful comes from an ancient Buddhist practice called tonglen. Tonglen involves confronting pain, and in fact, opening the heart. It appears to be the opposite of how you might ever imagine you could ever deal with pain or hold yourself together. In this practice, you breathe in the suffering of others—even of those who have harmed or hated you. Yes. You take it in, instead of avoiding it. It is a way to confront the pain head-on and open the heart. It means acknowledging the pain in yourself and the other, and then hold a space of kindness around the injury instead of using the armor of hate. Then-and this is challenging at first, you breathe out the fear and resistance, sending calm and nourishment to the source of suffering. At first, such a practice seems almost impossible, because the mind is often hard-wired to feel tightness, anger, or revulsion in response to painful circumstances or difficult people. But tonglen is a practice of gradual steps. It is a practice, not simply a magical formula. But just the intention to breathe like this can increase compassion for yourself and for the situation, as impossible as it may be.

To let go of the crust of hatred can actually strengthen, not weaken us. That does not mean everything is fine. You still must set boundaries, trust your gut, and make a space for self care and self defense if need be. But practicing such compassion, or at least respect for yourself in this process can impact the way you preserve your feelings towards others.

Kindness. It takes time to heal and to think things through. But it is an important part of the journey of grief and fierce compassion to restore the love inside that has been lost or never felt at all. Perhaps this is a road to heal, practicing the wildpeace of kindness instead of hate...

-Mikele Rauch

Before you know kindness as the deepest thing inside,

you must know sorrow as the other deepest thing.

You must wake up with sorrow.

You must speak to it till your voice

catches the thread of all sorrows

and you see the size of the cloth.

Then it is only kindness that makes sense anymore...

--Naomi Shihab Nye

Recovery After Betrayal... The Power of Community

I don’t know you.

I don’t trust you.

How could I believe you?

Why would I trust you?

I want to trust.

I want to believe you.

I want to believe myself.

Betrayal: when the ones on which a person depends for survival significantly violate that person' s well-being...

Betrayal can profoundly devastate your safety. This experience can be embedded deep inside as a template for the future, holding you back, keeping you apart, afraid to connect.

Betrayal can happen when the details of the past provoke a reaction in the moment. Memory and present experience can feel mercurial. The mind can resonate and then forget in dissociation, like the quicksand of voice or faces after a dream. The mind may be flooded with a force field of feeling with no explanation. Current events or the memory of trauma can be in a smell, a sound, a mental snapshot; you see with the nose; you hear with the tongue. You feel in silence or chaos with a sense of neglect and abandonment.

The feeling of betrayal will show up in triggers that seem to come out of nowhere when even a fragment of the past shows up: a word, a gesture, a hint of patronizing. Family, partners, institutions, countries, churches, organizations may have betrayed you. You have to reckon with the collision of confusion and dependence that make it so hard to trust again or have conditioned you to continue to choose people that recreate your past. Then if things fall apart, you may automatically take the blame or simply retreat back into yourself. Sometimes it seems easier to self sabotage or take the blame yourself than to consider who was actually responsible for not protecting or responding to you.

Perhaps you have tried far too many times to find the key to feel safe after the betrayal of abuse. EMDR, therapy, yoga, self help books...drugs. There have been so many moments, so many starts and stops. Perhaps you have been waiting for a long time to blurt out the whole story. Maybe you cannot say what you went through because often there are no words.

You recognize that healing will not be simple because this process of recovery isn't just about the sexual abuse. It is about all the other elements of tumult and betrayals that may have made up your life. The lies, the secrets, the shame imposed by the ones who harmed you may still caution you to keep quiet. Maybe you have had to lie or diminish your story just to be sure that whoever listens to you can bear a piece of the truth. Perhaps you have left therapy because it was so hard to move forward, or you sensed you were not really seen. Maybe you could not assess whether the therapist was for real. If they had bad boundaries, it compromised or destroyed your safety yet again. You may wonder if it is worth the risk to find another way get out of this hole of loneliness and fear.

You just want to heal. So, you persist.

But the journey is truly worth every stop and start. It may not be easy to find a professional who is capable and committed to your recovery who you can count on to allow you to be vulnerable and powerful at the same time. You will have to ask hard questions, check your intuition, test the waters of safety and truth, and remain fierce and gentle with yourself in the process.

It also can take some time to find a community of support and learn to trust others again, but this is one of the most important parts of recovery. It is a series of small steps out of your comfort zone to look for a group where you finally feel seen and safe. You may be surprised who shows up to be the ones you most trust.

Eventually you begin to connect the dots because you have others to relate to that share your struggles. Even in confusion or clarity, you move in and through fear on a new path forward because you are not alone.

Something can open.

Respect. Movement. Stillness. Words. Push back. Pull in. Deconstruct. Remember. Recreate. Rework. Repeat. Laugh. Listen.

Connect.

We are out here.

This Week

The past week’s war in Gaza has added more sorrow to a year of conflict across the globe. It has filled our world with grief and sorrow, anger and fear. We mourn the those slaughtered in the terrorist attack and those innocent victims both Israeli and Palestinian, who like so many victims of war, are caught in the middle.

Today we stand with the people of Israel who have struggled for centuries to be free--and we stand with the people of Palestine, who continue to live under intolerable oppression.

As humans, we must acknowledge that we are dependent on one another. As survivors, we know only too well that retribution and violence do not heal.

The Question

Let us simmer over our incalculable cauldron, our enthralling confusion, our hotch-potch of impulses, our perpetual miracle — for the soul throws up wonders every second.

—Virginia Woolf

Sometimes, we just don't understand why or what or how.

Sometimes the question overwhelms any answer we could possibly give to the grief, the loss, or sudden change in circumstance or history.

We may have been conditioned not to know how to respond to change without allegiance to what we learned from our family or culture. Perhaps we have been shamed or punished if we challenged the norms of our communities. Maybe we were alone in our thoughts or questions. If no one else was really there to support us to think for ourselves or help us through, it was hard to trust or find a safe space to land. We may have built cocoons of apparent safety or comfort, sometimes at the cost of living a fuller life that would include dipping into the unknown.

Surely, in the journey of recovery, our old beliefs about ourselves can fall apart. However, the part we possibly never trusted in ourselves can grow, quickening the impulse to question. At these junctures, and throughout the life ahead, this kind of inquiry may beckon us to reach deeper inside and utilize a new curiosity despite the old prompts of shame or fear.

Perhaps we stop and consider the question beyond any previous answer, and then approach and even embrace what is yet unknown.

Our eyelids flutter as we awaken to the bright wind of change. Those questions remain; in fact, we have more questions than ever. It is what happens with growth.

Indeed, it is the questions beyond the creaking door that remind us that we are truly and wondrously alive.

We open the door.